I Tested the Nyx Lipliner Brownie Pie: My Honest Take After Trying Them

It earned its ranking through sheer color intensity, delivering a deeply saturated punch of pigment that commands attention. You get a stark, uncompromising dark brown that anchors heavy glam looks without fading into obscurity.

In my view, this pencil is a heavy hitter for anyone craving maximum contrast. I would rank this lower for daytime wear because the tone reads quite severe on fair complexions.

This shade is tailored for warm neutrals who want a softer approach to the brown lip trend. You get a comforting, mellow shade that pairs effortlessly with peachy glosses and golden highlighters.

I find this color much more approachable for everyday office wear than its darker siblings. What I look for in a daily liner is versatility, and this one delivers without demanding a complete face of makeup.

A surprisingly luscious texture sets this gloss apart from traditional waxy pencils, melting onto the lips with cushiony comfort. You get a high-shine finish that mimics melted chocolate while offering a sheer wash of deep brown warmth.

I appreciate how this formula plumps the look of your lips optically without stinging or tingling. I would place this at the top of your cart if you hate dry matte textures.

The most common buyer complaint centers on its tendency to require frequent sharpening due to the soft wooden barrel. You get the exact shade match for the viral brownie pie aesthetic, making the minor upkeep a fair trade-off.

I rank this as the ultimate winner because the brownish-pink balance flatters an enormous range of skin tones. In my estimation, this is the holy grail shade of the entire line.

Much like the Peekaboo Neutral option above, this pencil relies on a dependable wooden design, but it veers into much richer red undertones. You get a spicy, burnt-sugar depth that warms up your entire complexion instantly.

I prefer this shade when I want my lip liner to demand a second glance. In my judgment, it offers a more dramatic punch than Coffee while remaining easier to wear than Espresso.

Its reputation grew rapidly as a safe everyday contour, praised for offering subtle definition without looking harsh. You receive a muted, neutral brown that simply mimics natural shadow rather than screaming for attention.

I think the hype is mostly justified if you prefer a subtle, understated makeup routine. I would steer you toward this option if you fear looking like you stepped out of a 1990s music video.