Printer ink is often more expensive by volume than vintage champagne, yet we rarely consider the cost per page until the warning light flashes. After reviewing user sentiment across the Canon 245 line, I have analyzed the performance trade-offs for you. My goal is to help you bypass the marketing noise. Here is how these genuine ink cartridges stack up against one another in a ranked comparison.
| Best For | Product | Name | Score | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Occasional Light Printing |  |
Canon PG-245 Genuine Black Ink Cartridge, Compatible with iP2820, MG2420/2924/2920/3020/2522/2525, MX492, TS3120/302/302a/202/202a/4520/3320 | 9.8/10 | View on Amazon |
| Frequent Heavy Users |  |
Canon PG-245 XL / CL-246 XL Genuine Ink Value Pack (2 Cartridges), Compatible with iP2820, MG2420/2924/2920/3020/2522/2525, MX492, TS3120/302/302a/202/202a/4520/3320 | 9.3/10 | View on Amazon |
| High Volume Printing |  |
Canon PG-245 XL Genuine Black Ink Cartridge, Compatible with iP2820, MG2420/2924/2920/3020/2522/2525, MX492, TS3120/302/302a/202/202a/4520/3320 | 8.8/10 | View on Amazon |
| Standard Home Office |  |
Canon Genuine Ink PG-245 / CL-246 Value Pack (2 Cartridges) | 8.2/10 | View on Amazon |
1. Canon PG-245 Genuine Black Ink Cartridge, Compatible with iP2820, MG2420/2924/2920/3020/2522/2525, MX492, TS3120/302/302a/202/202a/4520/3320
This cartridge earns its place for its minimal upfront cost, making it the sensible choice for occasional printing needs. It functions like a simple light switch, providing basic output for those who print only a few documents each month.
I find that this standard version is best suited for students or homeowners who rarely reach for their printer. You avoid the larger financial commitment of high-capacity models while maintaining genuine print quality. However, you will find yourself replacing it much sooner than the XL alternatives.
Buyers appreciate the lower entry price for infrequent use.
The standard capacity requires more frequent cartridge changes.
Users report consistent print clarity for basic text documents.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Canon PG-245 XL / CL-246 XL Genuine Ink Value Pack (2 Cartridges), Compatible with iP2820, MG2420/2924/2920/3020/2522/2525, MX492, TS3120/302/302a/202/202a/4520/3320
This combo pack is designed for the frequent heavy user who needs both black and color ink on hand at all times. It acts as a safety net for your home office, ensuring you are not stalled by an empty color tank during a critical project.
In my view, buying these together is the most efficient way to maintain a functional printing environment. You get the high-capacity versions, which significantly reduces the frequency of your shopping trips. Just be mindful that the initial purchase price is higher than standard, single-cartridge options.
Frequent users prefer the convenience of the bundled black and color ink.
The XL capacity helps avoid the frustration of mid-project supply depletion.
Owners note the value of keeping a full set ready for varied printing tasks.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Canon PG-245 XL Genuine Black Ink Cartridge, Compatible with iP2820, MG2420/2924/2920/3020/2522/2525, MX492, TS3120/302/302a/202/202a/4520/3320
A fascinating feature of this cartridge is its optimized ink density, which allows for a significantly higher page yield without increasing the physical footprint of the unit. It is the marathon runner of the group, built specifically to handle high-volume demands.
I consider this my top recommendation because it offers the best value long-term. It is the most reliable option for anyone printing reports, labels, or assignments on a daily basis. My only caution is that you must ensure your printer is compatible with the XL designation before purchasing.
Heavy-duty users favor the increased page yield of the XL series.
The cartridge maintains consistent quality throughout its longer lifespan.
Buyers emphasize the lower cost per page as the primary benefit.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Canon Genuine Ink PG-245 / CL-246 Value Pack (2 Cartridges)
The most common complaint regarding this set is that the standard capacity ink runs dry faster than expected during color-heavy tasks. Despite this, it remains a balanced option for the standard home office that requires a mix of black text and occasional color images.
I appreciate that this pack covers the basics without requiring a massive upfront investment. It is a solid middle-ground solution for those who want to keep printing costs manageable. Keep in mind that you will be changing these cartridges more often than the high-capacity alternatives.
Occasional users find the standard capacity sufficient for light home needs.
Buyers sometimes note the rapid consumption of color ink during photo printing.
The value pack is seen as a simple way to restock essential supplies.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Choosing Between Them
If you print frequently, my top recommendation is the Canon PG-245 XL because it offers the lowest cost per page, which saves you money over time. For those with more varied needs, the PG-245 XL/CL-246 XL Value Pack is the ideal choice for the frequent heavy user who needs a complete solution. Casual users are better served by the standard cartridges, as they provide a lower entry price for light work.
Please remember that choosing original manufacturer ink is an investment in your printer’s longevity. While third-party alternatives exist, they often lack the consistent performance and reliability of genuine Canon products. You should weigh your monthly volume against the higher upfront cost to ensure you are getting the best value for your specific printing habits.
As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Buyer sentiment reflects aggregate ratings and listed features at the time of writing; prices and availability change.