Most runners assume a higher price tag guarantees a better shoe, yet the New Balance 680 series proves that mid-range engineering often outperforms expensive, over-cushioned alternatives. After reviewing buyer feedback and comparing these nine variants, I have analyzed which iterations deliver actual value. I found that consistent performance is the primary driver for this series. Below is my honest, ranked comparison of these dependable running shoes.
1. New Balance Men's Fresh Foam 680 V8 Running Shoe, Fresh Foam 680 V8, 9
This model claims the top spot for general use because it offers the most balanced feel for daily training. It avoids the gimmicks found in pricier shoes, focusing instead on a reliable Fresh Foam midsole.
In my view, this is the most sensible starting point for anyone seeking a neutral trainer. While it lacks the plushness of high-end lines, it provides enough structure for those logging regular miles.
Buyers frequently praise the consistent arch support provided by this model.
The standard fit remains a baseline for comparison across the series.
Users report it holds up well under moderate weekly mileage.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. New Balance Women's Fresh Foam 680 v9 Running Shoe Black/Phantom
This version is best for the runner who prioritizes neutral support and a lightweight feel during their sessions. It specifically targets women who need a shoe that disappears on the foot rather than drawing attention to itself.
I think the move to the V9 iteration offers a slightly more refined heel lock. It is a subtle update, but it addresses the stability needs of the everyday runner.
Female buyers note that the sizing is consistent with previous releases.
The streamlined design is often cited as a benefit for gym sessions.
Many users appreciate the lighter weight compared to older versions.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. New Balance Men's Fresh Foam 680 V9 Running Shoe, Black/Faded Black, 10.5 W
You might be surprised to find that the extra-wide toe box is the standout feature here, providing room where most standard trainers pinch. This design choice shifts the focus from speed to pure, unadulterated comfort for longer sessions.
I consider this the most inclusive fit in the group. If you struggle with lateral pressure, this model is the most logical upgrade.
Feedback indicates this width accommodates orthotics better than the standard model.
Users with broader feet report less friction during long runs.
The structure remains firm despite the increased internal space.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. New Balance Men's Fresh Foam 680 V8
The most common complaint regarding this shoe is its firmer ride, which can feel jarring if you are accustomed to soft, maximalist foam. However, this stiffness is exactly why it earns a spot in my rankings for entry-level miles.
It acts like a sturdy foundation, providing the ground feel that beginner runners often lack. I would suggest this for those who prefer durability over cloud-like softness.
Beginners often highlight the shoe's longevity as a primary advantage.
Some users mention the break-in period is slightly longer than expected.
The exterior mesh is described as highly resistant to general wear.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. New Balance Men's Fresh Foam 680 V8 Running Shoe, Fresh Foam 680 V8, 9 (Option 2)
Compared to the V8 Basic, this variant offers a more consistent neutral stride by refining the transition from heel to toe. It serves as a natural step up for those who found the basic model too rigid.
I prefer this iteration for its fluid geometry. It is not a dramatic change, but it smooths out the impact for a more predictable landing.
Users report a smoother transition during mid-foot strikes.
The midsole density is described as more uniform than the entry-level V8.
Consistent feedback suggests this model maintains its shape over time.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
6. New Balance Men's Fresh Foam 680 V8 Waterproof Running Shoe, Black/Castlerock/Lab Green, 11 M
This model gained popularity for its weather-resistant upper, which keeps feet dry during sudden storms. After reviewing the claims, I believe it successfully delivers on that promise without sacrificing too much breathability.
It is my top recommendation because it adds essential utility for those who do not let rain stop their training. It is the most versatile tool in this entire lineup.
Runners in wet climates consistently rank this as their favorite variant.
The weatherproofing does not seem to affect the overall flex of the shoe.
Users note that the material is surprisingly easy to clean after muddy runs.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
7. New Balance Men's Fresh Foam 680 V8 Running Shoe, Fresh Foam 680 V8, 10.5
The primary reason this model ranks well is its exceptional versatility for the mid-size foot. It hits a sweet spot that feels neither too wide nor too narrow, catering to a vast majority of runners.
I find the balanced fit to be its greatest strength. It is a no-nonsense shoe that fits like a glove right out of the box.
Buyers frequently mention the comfortable heel collar padding.
The lacing system allows for a secure, customized lockdown.
Many users highlight the overall weight as being ideal for tempo runs.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
8. New Balance Women's Fresh Foam 680 V8 Running Shoe, Angora/Linen/Stoneware, 8 W
This version is best for the buyer who wants a shoe that transitions from a morning run to coffee with friends. Its aesthetic leanings make it a top pick for those who value style as much as function.
I appreciate that it does not look like a traditional, bulky technical trainer. It serves a specific, lifestyle-oriented niche within the performance category.
Fashion-conscious runners often cite the color options as a deciding factor.
Users find the cushioning adequate for walking throughout the day.
The low-profile design is frequently praised for its visual appeal.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
9. NEW Balance Fresh Foam 680 v8 White/Black, 46.5 EU, White/Black, 9.5
An interesting feature of this model is its EU-specific sizing, which offers a slightly different internal volume than the standard US models. This wideness in the midfoot provides a unique, accommodating fit for those who find US sizes restrictive.
I think this is an underrated option for anyone who struggles with standard sizing conventions. It is a simple adjustment that significantly changes the overall comfort level.
International buyers note that the fit is precise and true to the EU scale.
Users report that the upper material feels slightly more supple in this version.
Feedback suggests the arch placement is slightly more neutral than in other V8 models.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Choosing Between Them
The waterproof V8 model is my clear top choice for those wanting a functional, all-weather trainer, while the standard Fresh Foam 680 V8 remains the best fit for someone seeking a reliable daily driver. If you have specific needs, the Wide V9 is excellent for extra space, and the casual women's version is perfect for those prioritizing style. I recommend selecting based on your climate and foot shape rather than just chasing the latest model number.
Keep in mind that the Fresh Foam cushioning in this series feels firmer than the premium line. If you are coming from ultra-soft shoes, expect a period of adjustment while your feet adapt to this more responsive, stable foundation.
As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Buyer sentiment reflects aggregate ratings and listed features at the time of writing; prices and availability change.
