I Tested Monterey Bay Herb Co, Here’s My Honest Take

This giant bag earned its spot at the top of the pantry hierarchy through sheer value and volume. You get a massive eight ounces of dried leaves, which will comfortably outlast any standard spice rack jar by years.

I think this is the smart play for anyone who burns through bay leaves in heavy soups and slow-cooked stocks. The main limitation is the massive storage footprint required for such a large bag.

This smaller container is tailored specifically for the occasional home cook who only needs a pinch of flavor once in a while. You get whole leaves without committing to a bulk bag that loses potency in the back of your cupboard.

I would point most weekend chefs toward this size to prevent waste. The obvious drawback is the higher cost per ounce compared to commercial bulk alternatives.

An unusual liquid format sets this apart from typical dried leaves, delivering a concentrated extract designed for specific routines. You apply this oil topically rather than tossing it into a simmering pot of broth.

I find this format fascinating for targeted care, though it departs entirely from traditional culinary uses. The specialized nature means you are paying a premium price for a tiny one-ounce bottle.

A lack of substantial quantity is the most common complaint leveled against this tiny package, yet it remains a popular choice. You receive a minuscule amount that will disappear after just a few culinary experiments.

I suggest skipping this unless you only need a single leaf for a special recipe. The meager zero-point-one-five ounce size simply does not offer good value for money.

Unlike the tiny retail packets mentioned above, this one-pound bulk option provides unmatched household supply for serious kitchens. You get a mountain of aromatic thyme that easily undercuts grocery store pricing per ounce.

This stands as my favorite pick because it balances exceptional bulk value with reliable herbal quality. You do need to invest in airtight jars to keep the massive supply fresh over time.

A reputation for dependable restaurant supply quality drove the popularity of this classic container. You get a sturdy little shaker bottle designed for quick access during busy meal prep.

I appreciate the straightforward utility of this jar, even if it lacks gourmet flair. The modest one-point-five ounce capacity means you will be restocking sooner rather than later.