Losing access to a secure storage box brings an instant wave of panic. I have reviewed buyer feedback and compared the market to see which replacement keys actually solve this frustration. In my view, getting back into your lockbox should not require a locksmith. Let us examine an honest, ranked comparison of your best options.
| Best For | Product | Name | Score | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stack-On Safe Owners | ![]() |
Replacement Keys for Stack-On Safes & Boxes for Key Codes GL200-GL249 2-Keys SafeCo Brands (GL245) | 9.8/10 | View on Amazon |
| Sentry Safe 2073 Codes | ![]() |
3-Pack 2073 Tubular Replacement Keys Cut to Code 2001–2100 Compatible with for Sentry Safe, Round Barrel Key Type | 9.5/10 | View on Amazon |
| Sentry Safe 2071 Codes | ![]() |
3-Pack 2071 Tubular Replacement Keys Cut to Code 2001–2100 Compatible with for Sentry Safe, Round Barrel Key Type | 9.2/10 | View on Amazon |
| Sentry Safe 004 Models | ![]() |
Safe Lock Replacement Key for Sentry Safe/Schwab 004 | 8.9/10 | View on Amazon |
| Sentry 1100 Series | ![]() |
2 Pack B Replacement Safe Keys, Compatible with Sentry Safes 1100, 1150, 1170, Single-Sided Key Cut to Code A-Z | 8.6/10 | View on Amazon |
| Sentry C-code Models | ![]() |
2 Pack C Replacement Safe Keys, Compatible with Sentry Safes 1100, 1150, 1170, Single-Sided Key Cut to Code A-Z | 8.2/10 | View on Amazon |
1. Replacement Keys for Stack-On Safes & Boxes for Key Codes GL200-GL249 2-Keys SafeCo Brands (GL245)
This option earned its specific ranking through precise code matching for Stack-On safes. If your code falls in the GL200 to GL249 range, this set cuts out the guesswork. I find that targeted specialty items save you from endless trial and error.
The manufacturer cuts these keys to factory specifications for exact compatibility. You simply provide your code during purchase and wait for delivery. In my evaluation of similar spares, precision matters above all else.
Buyers frequently confirm that these blanks turn smoothly in the original lock cylinder.
Users appreciate having an exact factory-matched duplicate on hand.
The primary limitation is strict code dependency, leaving zero room for typos.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. 3-Pack 2073 Tubular Replacement Keys Cut to Code 2001–2100 Compatible with for Sentry Safe, Round Barrel Key Type
This product is best for owners who need a round barrel design for specific Sentry models. Tubular keys look intimidating, but they serve a distinct mechanical purpose. I consider this particular configuration essential for maintaining high-security access.
You receive a three-pack, which provides a sensible margin for error. Losing one spare still leaves you with backups for your drawer or desk. In my assessment, multi-pack offerings provide much better long-term value.
Customers note that the barrel fits the cylindrical keyway without catching.
Reviewers mention that getting three copies eliminates immediate panic over future misplacement.
The main drawback is that a single incorrect digit renders all three keys useless.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. 3-Pack 2071 Tubular Replacement Keys Cut to Code 2001–2100 Compatible with for Sentry Safe, Round Barrel Key Type
The most interesting aspect here is the precision pin-pattern inside the cylindrical shaft. While many replacement options feel generic, these require exact factory cutting parameters. I view this level of detail as a strong indicator of reliable manufacturing.
Stepping down the code range from the previous option requires careful verification. You must match your specific lock stamp before ordering. In my research, overlooking tiny numerical differences is the number one cause of failed orders.
Users report that the metal stock feels heavy and durable in hand.
Buyers emphasize the importance of double-checking the code stamped on the original lock face.
The sole constraint is that barrel keys demand careful alignment during insertion.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Safe Lock Replacement Key for Sentry Safe/Schwab 004
The most common buyer complaint involves the frustrating lack of stamped identification numbers on older locks. When your safe lacks visible markings, finding the correct replacement feels like solving a riddle. I think single-key purchases carry higher stakes for this exact reason.
You need to rely heavily on visual matching rather than a simple numeric code. This requires patience and a careful comparison against product photographs. In my view, visual verification demands much more scrutiny than entering a standard code.
Customers frequently mention the relief of finding legacy keys for older security boxes.
Reviewers note that the single key arrives cut and ready for immediate use.
The primary limitation is the uncertainty of ordering without a confirmed manufacturer code.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. 2 Pack B Replacement Safe Keys, Compatible with Sentry Safes 1100, 1150, 1170, Single-Sided Key Cut to Code A-Z
Moving past the tubular designs, this single-sided option improves upon the simpler keyway found in standard lockboxes. Unlike the rigid barrel configurations above, this traditional flat key slides into place with minimal resistance. I'd rank this first because the B-code series covers a vast number of household safes.
Getting a two-pack gives you a primary key and a hidden spare. Sentry units in the 1100 series rely heavily on this exact profile. In my judgment, this represents the most practical balance of convenience and reliability.
Buyers consistently highlight the quick turnaround time for custom cuts.
Users praise the smooth operation of the flat metal edge inside the lock.
The main hurdle is ensuring your lock stamp falls strictly within the A-Z sequence.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
6. 2 Pack C Replacement Safe Keys, Compatible with Sentry Safes 1100, 1150, 1170, Single-Sided Key Cut to Code A-Z
This alternative gained traction due to widespread demand for legacy lock variations across the popular 1100 safety lineup. Many buyers discover they have a C-code unit only after trying other standard blanks. I think this market reputation holds up well for owners sorting through mixed household security boxes.
The two-pack configuration mirrors my top pick while adjusting the internal biting pattern. You still get a dependable backup for your storage box. In my view, having a dedicated spare is non-negotiable for important documents.
Customers state that the keys slide into the tumblers without needing force.
Reviewers appreciate the straightforward ordering process for specific letter codes.
The notable limitation is that C-codes and B-codes are entirely mutually exclusive.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Choosing Between Them
Choosing the correct replacement key comes down to matching your exact hardware code, and my top recommendation is the Sentry 1100 Series B-code pack for its broad utility. If you own a specialized tubular lock, the Sentry 2073 and 2071 codes suit those specific cylindrical requirements, while Stack-On owners will want the dedicated SafeCo Brands GL245 option. Legacy units like the Schwab 004 and the C-code variants round out the list for specific archival boxes.
Keep in mind that compatibility risks remain high if your lock was ever modified or replaced over the lifetime of the safe. Always double-check your stamped numbers before ordering any custom-cut metal.
As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Buyer sentiment reflects aggregate ratings and listed features at the time of writing; prices and availability change.




