Most buyers mistakenly prioritize aesthetics over functional efficiency when upgrading their Super Nova. I have analyzed current buyer feedback to filter out the noise and identify which modifications truly serve the shooter. My rankings prioritize practical reliability and ease of installation. Let’s look at how these five options stack up, from the essential gear to the purely cosmetic choices.
| Best For | Product | Name | Score | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Quick Ammo Access |  |
Trinity 6-Round Shell Holder Compatible with Benelli Supernova – 12 Gauge Carrier with Hook and Loop Mount – Made in USA | 9.8/10 | View on Amazon |
| Mounting Optics Securely |  |
EGW Benelli Super Nova Pump Shotgun Scope Mount | 9.4/10 | View on Amazon |
| Reducing Felt Recoil |  |
Benelli ComforTech Shotgun Recoil Pad – Right Hand Only – 14-3/4" Length of Pull – Compatible with Benelli Vinci & Super Vinci 12 Gauge Shotguns – Black | 9.0/10 | View on Amazon |
| Tactical Rail Upgrades |  |
Eastern Tactical Supply Beneli Super Nova Picatinny Rail Mount (Black) | 8.6/10 | View on Amazon |
| Color Coordinated Setups |  |
Eastern Tactical Supply Beneli Super Nova Picatinny Rail Mount (Tan) | 8.2/10 | View on Amazon |
1. Trinity 6-Round Shell Holder Compatible with Benelli Supernova – 12 Gauge Carrier with Hook and Loop Mount – Made in USA
This carrier earns the top spot because it balances rapid access with a low profile. It transforms your receiver into a staging area, ensuring you never fumble for shells during a high-speed reload.
I find this to be the most logical upgrade for anyone serious about performance. The hook and loop system is clever, though you should ensure your receiver surface is cleaned thoroughly to prevent the adhesive from failing under heat.
Buyers consistently praise the quick mounting process.
The 6-round capacity is frequently cited as the ideal balance for weight.
Users appreciate the durable material used in the carrier construction.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. EGW Benelli Super Nova Pump Shotgun Scope Mount
This mount is for the shooter who demands a rock-solid foundation for optics. If you are tired of your red dot or scope shifting after a few heavy loads, this hardware provides the rigidity you need.
I consider this the industry standard for reliable mounting on a pump shotgun. It is straightforward and keeps the optic locked in place, though it does add a slight amount of bulk to the top of the receiver.
Reviewers often highlight the precision fit on the Super Nova receiver.
The mounting holes line up perfectly with factory pre-drilled ports.
Many users value the sturdy build quality of the base.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. Benelli ComforTech Shotgun Recoil Pad – Right Hand Only – 14-3/4" Length of Pull – Compatible with Benelli Vinci & Super Vinci 12 Gauge Shotguns – Black
The most interesting feature here is how it uses specialized geometry to manage energy absorption. It acts like a shock absorber for your shoulder, spreading the force of heavy shells over a wider surface area.
I think this is a must-have for anyone who spends long sessions at the range. While it is excellent for recoil, you must be aware that it is specifically designed for right-handed shooters, which limits its appeal for some.
Buyers report a noticeable reduction in fatigue during long sessions.
The fit is described as snug and professional.
Many users note that it maintains the original look of the stock.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. Eastern Tactical Supply Beneli Super Nova Picatinny Rail Mount (Black)
The most common complaint involves the weight and the way it slightly changes the handling balance of the shotgun. However, if you need a versatile platform for lights or lasers, this rail is a workhorse.
In my view, the added versatility outweighs the minor weight penalty. It creates a tactical profile that is hard to beat for home defense setups, provided you don't mind the slightly protruding profile of the metal.
Users commonly note the heavy-duty construction of the rail.
Feedback suggests the black finish matches most factory receivers well.
The installation is widely considered a straightforward task.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Eastern Tactical Supply Beneli Super Nova Picatinny Rail Mount (Tan)
This rail is functionally identical to the black version but caters specifically to those building a color-coordinated setup. It serves the same purpose as its sibling but offers a distinct look for desert or multi-terrain gear themes.
I would suggest this only if you are committed to a specific color scheme. It is a niche choice, and the tan finish can be prone to showing scuffs more easily than the black anodized version.
Buyers appreciate the unique color match for custom builds.
The rail dimensions are identical to the black model, ensuring consistent compatibility.
Many owners note the tan finish is uniform across the entire piece.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Choosing Between Them
The Trinity 6-Round Shell Holder is my top recommendation for those seeking practical utility and speed, while the EGW Scope Mount serves the precision shooter best. If comfort is your priority, the ComforTech Recoil Pad is a wise investment, and the Eastern Tactical Rail options provide the necessary foundation for those adding lights or lasers to their tactical setups.
I want to offer one important caveat: check your local laws and specific receiver finish before permanently attaching any adhesive or bolt-on gear. While these accessories enhance the Super Nova platform, they can occasionally interfere with specific aftermarket stocks or specialized sights if not installed with careful attention to clearance and alignment.
As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Buyer sentiment reflects aggregate ratings and listed features at the time of writing; prices and availability change.