Dental hygiene has moved toward specialized formulas that prioritize specific oral needs over generic cleaning. I have analyzed market trends and buyer feedback to compare these five popular options. While I find the brand's signature baking soda base consistent, the results vary significantly. Here is my honest ranking of these formulas to help you decide which is truly worth your bathroom counter space.
| Best For | Product | Name | Score | |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Stain Removal |  |
ARM & HAMMER Advance White Toothpaste, Clean Mint, 6.0 oz, 4-Pack | 9.8/10 | View on Amazon |
| Gum Health |  |
ARM & Hammer Peroxicare Toothpaste, Clean Mint, 6.0 oz, 4-Pack | 9.4/10 | View on Amazon |
| Daily Maintenance |  |
ARM & HAMMER Complete Care Toothpaste, Fresh Mint, 6.0 oz | 9.0/10 | View on Amazon |
| Bulk Value |  |
ARM & Hammer Complete Care Toothpaste, Fresh Mint, 6.0 oz, 4-Pack | 8.6/10 | View on Amazon |
| Bad Breath |  |
ARM & HAMMER Plus TheraBreath Toothpaste, Icy Mint, 5.5 oz, 2-Pack | 8.2/10 | View on Amazon |
1. ARM & HAMMER Advance White Toothpaste, Clean Mint, 6.0 oz, 4-Pack
This formula takes the top spot because it excels at stain removal without the harsh abrasiveness found in many whitening gels. It effectively lifts surface discoloration while maintaining a polish that feels professional.
In my view, this is the most balanced option for anyone who consumes coffee or tea regularly. It manages to brighten your smile while keeping sensitivity in check, which is a rare feat in this category.
Users often report noticeable brightening after consistent use.
The texture is generally described as smoother than other grit-heavy whitening pastes.
It remains a favorite for those wanting a brighter smile without expensive treatments.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. ARM & Hammer Peroxicare Toothpaste, Clean Mint, 6.0 oz, 4-Pack
If you prioritize gum health and deep cleaning, this is the specific tool you need in your cabinet. It uses peroxide to reach areas where standard formulas might struggle, acting like a gentle disinfectant for your entire mouth.
I think the foaming action is particularly satisfying for people who feel that a standard clean is not enough. It creates a bubbly sensation that helps you reach between teeth, making it ideal for those prone to inflammation.
Buyers appreciate the clean, refreshed feeling that lasts well past the initial brush.
The formula is often recommended for those focused on preventing gum irritation.
It is frequently cited as a preferred choice for a deep, medicinal-feeling clean.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. ARM & HAMMER Complete Care Toothpaste, Fresh Mint, 6.0 oz
An unexpected feature of this paste is its inclusion of liquid calcium, which works to repair enamel surfaces by filling in tiny imperfections. Beyond this restorative work, it functions as a reliable, all-around daily maintenance product.
I find this to be the most sensible option for a household that wants one tube to cover every base. It is not trying to be a miracle worker, but it does exactly what a standard, high-quality paste should do every morning and night.
Many appreciate the simple, no-nonsense approach to daily hygiene.
The mint flavor is widely considered balanced and not overly aggressive.
It is a go-to for those who want enamel support without sacrificing breath freshness.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. ARM & Hammer Complete Care Toothpaste, Fresh Mint, 6.0 oz, 4-Pack
The most common complaint with this bulk offering is the sheer size of the shipment: if you do not have the storage space, four large tubes can become a burden. Once you move past the logistics of your cupboard, however, the value is undeniable.
I believe this is the smartest financial move for a family that uses this specific formula daily. You are essentially paying for the convenience of never running out, which provides a level of peace of mind that justifies the initial bulk investment.
Buyers frequently mention that the unit price makes this the most economical choice.
The expiration dates are long enough that the quantity is rarely an issue for families.
It is the preferred option for those who dislike frequent trips to the store.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. ARM & HAMMER Plus TheraBreath Toothpaste, Icy Mint, 5.5 oz, 2-Pack
Compared to the bulk value pack above, this option focuses entirely on breath control rather than raw volume. It combines the cleaning power of baking soda with the specific neutralizing agents found in TheraBreath, making it a targeted solution for odor.
I think this is a specialized tool rather than a daily workhorse for everyone. If you struggle with persistent breath concerns, this is the one I would point you toward because it attacks the source of the issue rather than just masking it with mint.
Users commonly note a significant improvement in breath quality throughout the day.
The taste profile is often described as cleaner and less "chemically" than other odor-fighting pastes.
It is highly regarded by those who prioritize fresh breath as their primary oral health goal.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Choosing Between Them
I recommend the Advance White formula for the majority of users, as it provides the most effective whitening results while remaining gentle on your enamel. For those with more specific needs, I suggest the Peroxicare for gum issues or the TheraBreath collaboration if breath freshness is your primary objective. The Complete Care options remain the most practical choice for routine maintenance, especially when purchased in bulk.
You should be prepared for the salty aftertaste that characterizes the entire Arm & Hammer line, as it is a direct consequence of the baking soda base. While some find this off-putting, I view it as a small price to pay for the superior cleaning performance these products deliver. Balancing your oral health needs with your flavor preferences is the key to finding the right match from this lineup.
As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Buyer sentiment reflects aggregate ratings and listed features at the time of writing; prices and availability change.