Cleaning the stubborn, baked-on grease from your Ninja FT205CO oven is a universal headache. I have reviewed the market data and user feedback to help you avoid the wrong purchase. Finding the right tray accessory is like choosing between a disposable sponge and a permanent tool. I am confident that my honest ranking will save you both time and unnecessary frustration. Let us see which of these five trays actually earns its place.
1. Reusable Silicone Tray Liners For Ninja Foodi Air Fryers Ovens DT201/DT251, 3 PCS
These liners earn their rank because they are the clear flexibility champions for anyone tired of scrubbing metal. Their soft construction means you can simply peel off dried residue or toss them directly into the dishwasher.
I find these most useful for delicate tasks that don't involve high-heat searing. Because they are silicone, they lack the structural rigidity of steel and can be floppy when moving them full of food.
Users appreciate the effort saved during cleanup.
The material is not designed for heavy-duty metal utensil use.
Ideal for owners who prioritize ease of maintenance over rigid support.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
2. Upgraded SP201 SP301 SP351 Crumb Tray Replacement Parts for Ninja Foodi Crumb Tray FT205CO Ninja Foodi Digital Air Fry Pro Countertop Flip Oven Bottom Tray 304 Stainless Steel Drip Pan Accessories
This is the heavy-duty choice for the serious home cook who treats their oven like a professional workstation. If you plan to use your Ninja oven daily for high-heat roasting, this is the robust, warp-resistant solution you need.
I prefer this option for its sheer durability. It feels like a permanent upgrade to the machine rather than a temporary cover. Just keep in mind that stainless steel requires a bit more soaking to keep it looking pristine compared to silicone.
Owners report the material holds up well under constant temperature cycling.
The fit is precise for the specified oven models.
A solid investment for users who rarely want to replace their drip pan.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
3. 304 Stainless Steel SP301 SP201 SP351 Crumb Tray Air Fryer Basket Replacement Parts for Ninja Air Fryer Tray Foodi Dual Heat Air Fry Oven FT205CO SP251Q FT301 FT201A Toaster Catch Drip Pan 2 Pcs
The most surprising feature here is the inclusion of a two-pack configuration at a price point that makes it the clear value leader. Having a spare tray ready while the other is in the wash is a game-changing convenience.
In my view, this is the top overall pick because it balances longevity with practical utility. The 304 stainless steel construction is resistant to rust and stains, ensuring it stays clean after multiple cooking sessions. It is the most reliable option for the majority of users.
The dual-pack design is highly praised for its utility.
The steel quality provides excellent resistance to heat damage.
It is widely considered the best value for money in the category.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
4. SP301 SP201 Crumb Tray Replacement for Ninja Bottom Pan 304 Stainless Steel Foodi Dual Heat Air Fry Oven SP351 FT205CO SP251Q FT301 FT201A Digital Air Fry Pro Countertop Oven Crumb Catcher Pan 1 Pcs
The most common complaint about this tray is that it lacks the spare backup offered by multi-packs, leaving you without a tray during cleaning. However, for those who only need a single replacement, it performs exactly as advertised without extra cost.
I think this is a fair trade-off for someone on a budget or with limited storage. It matches the original manufacturer quality well enough to keep your oven floor clean and protected.
Buyers note that the fit is snug and reliable.
It serves as an effective, no-frills replacement for a damaged original pan.
Some users feel the lack of a backup tray is a missed opportunity.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
5. Silicone Air Fryer Liners 2 Pack for Ninja 8-10 QT Dual Air Fryers | Reusable Liners Compatible with Foodi DZ201, DZ401, DZ550, COSORI, Chefman, Instant and 6-in-1 Air Fryer Baskets
These liners function similarly to the first pick, though they are specifically shaped for the dual-basket design of larger Ninja units. They provide the same silicone benefits as the first option but are tailored for those who cook two different items at once.
I would point you toward these if you own a multi-basket setup and need to keep your cleanup quick. They are highly efficient, though they require careful handling since they are lighter than the steel alternatives.
Users find the dual-size format essential for their specific oven type.
The silicone material is effective at preventing food from sticking.
Keep in mind these are not intended for high-heat broiling tasks.
Get It From Amazon Now: Check Price on Amazon & FREE Returns
Choosing Between Them
For most kitchens, my top recommendation is the 304 Stainless Steel Crumb Tray Set, as it offers the best balance of durable construction and daily value. If you focus primarily on baking, the Silicone Tray Liners are perfect for your needs, whereas the Upgraded Stainless Steel Crumb Tray suits those who prioritize heavy-duty performance. For those running dual-basket ovens, the specialized Dual Basket Silicone Liners will serve you best, while the Single Stainless Steel Crumb Catcher remains a sensible choice for a simple, one-off replacement.
Regardless of your choice, remember that metal trays offer superior longevity but require a bit more manual scrubbing than silicone options. While silicone is easier to wash, it will not withstand the same high-temperature abuse as your stainless steel components. Weigh your cooking style carefully against these materials to ensure the best fit for your routine.
As an Amazon Associate, this site earns from qualifying purchases. Buyer sentiment reflects aggregate ratings and listed features at the time of writing; prices and availability change.
